Propulsid (cisapride) — the Heartburn Blockbuster Pulled in 2000 After 80 Arrhythmia Deaths

When Janssen Pharmaceutica — the Belgian unit of Johnson & Johnson — announced on 23 March 2000 that it would stop general U.S. marketing of Propulsid, it presented the move as a precaution; the documented record shows a drug the company’s own labels had flagged as potentially lethal since 1995, kept on the open market for five more years while prescriptions ran past thirty million. Propulsid (cisapride) was a gastrointestinal prokinetic approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in 1993 for nighttime heartburn from gastroesophageal reflux. It worked by speeding the gut, but it also blocked a cardiac potassium channel, prolonging the QT interval and, in vulnerable patients, triggering torsades de pointes — a chaotic ventricular arrhythmia that can stop the heart.

The gap between the indication and the harm was the whole tragedy. Cisapride was approved for adult reflux, but its danger concentrated in people who should never have received it: patients taking common interacting drugs — the macrolide antibiotics erythromycin and clarithromycin, the antifungals ketoconazole, itraconazole and fluconazole — that raised cisapride’s blood levels, and patients with underlying cardiac or metabolic risk. By the FDA’s accounting, of the 341 serious arrhythmias and 80 deaths reported through December 1999, roughly 85 percent occurred in patients with a recognized contraindication or risk factor. The drug was, in effect, safe in the population that did not need protecting and dangerous in the population that did.

The verdict is therefore plain at the outset: an approved, widely prescribed heartburn pill killed through interactions its manufacturer and the FDA had named in the label years before the withdrawal, and a meaningful share of the dead were infants and children who received it off-label for colic and reflux even though it was never approved for pediatric use. One observational study of roughly 58,000 premature infants found that about a fifth had been given cisapride.

What followed was a slow regulatory unwind and a mass-tort settlement. Janssen halted general sale effective 14 July 2000, retaining only a tightly controlled limited-access protocol; in 2004 Johnson & Johnson agreed to pay up to $90 million to resolve claims that the drug caused some 300 deaths and nearly 16,000 injuries. Propulsid became the textbook case of a “Dear Doctor” letter and a black box that did not change prescribing fast enough to stop the dying.